





|
One day the research conducted by Beth Schwartz-Kenney
'86 may help put a criminal behind bars.
Recently tenured as an associate professor of psychology at Randolph-Macon
Woman's College, Schwartz-Kenney is working on a "lineup kit" designed to help
children identify strangers, a technique that could be applied in legal cases
involving eyewitness testimony.
According to Schwartz-Kenney, children as young as pre-school age can make
competent witnesses but lack the cognitive and linguistic abilities to
spontaneously report details of an event. Her research in children's eyewitness
memory involves "determining what types of things they can remember and what
types of things they can't." Her focus has settled on the latter because she
has found that children have difficulty reporting what a person looks like, an
obvious impediment to effective courtroom testimony. After investigating
techniques used in helping people identify suspects in criminal cases, she
found none that were appropriate for children. The traditional Ident-A-Kit
requires the user to subjectively create composite images of suspects from
transparencies of facial features, and it has a poor record of accuracy,
particularly when used by children, she says.
Her lineup kit includes eight characteristics--including hair color, eye
color, weight and height--to aid children in giving descriptions of persons
they don't know. Rather than verbalize their descriptions, children can select
pictures of, for instance, blue eyes, or use lines on a wall to approximate
height. "It gives them something concrete to point to, which we felt would help
them," Schwartz-Kenney said.
She says the new techniques still provide only a general description that is
useful in narrowing the field of suspects. "In reporting what a stranger looked
like, it would at least give the legal system some information on who can be
eliminated. It won't draw a picture," she said.
Schwartz-Kenney received her Ph.D. in cognitive psychology from SUNY-Buffalo
in 1991. Her interest in the field began, she says, as an undergraduate. "At
Colby I took a Jan Plan course on human factor psychology--it's a lot about how
people work together--which gave me a better idea of the kind of psychology I
wanted to work in," she said. "My honors paper at Colby dealt with eyewitness
testimony, so that also was an interest of mine."
Recently she has been researching children's understanding of secrecy, which
may help draw out the testimony of children who have witnessed an event but
been asked not to talk about it by the perpetrator. "What happens is that often
the children are keeping the information to themselves and then eventually
reporting it. Defense lawyers then can say that their story is not credible
because they have contradicted themselves," she said.
"I find that [area of research] intriguing because it deals with children's
understanding of the mind, how their mind works and how other people's minds
are different from their own," she said. "It gets more at the theory of
cognitive psychology."--Kevin Cool
|