Colby Magazine      
Contentsmag@colby.edumagazine search      
0 win03 0 0

Terror's Other Casualty
Civil liberties threatened by Bush security measures, journalists Anthony Lewis and David Broder say at Lovejoy Convocation Panel.
   
 

Daniel Pearl Died Honorably
Daniel Pearl, the Wall Street Journal reporter slain in Pakistan, recieves the Elijah Parish Lovejoy Award. His sister, Tamara Pearl, recalls his courage.

   
 

Iphigeneia's Truth
President Bro Adams on classical theater and looming war.

   
 

Anti-War
Colby protestors join Maine anti-war ranks.

   
 

Muehlner Leaves Miller
Suanne Muehlner presided over remarkable changes in Colby libraries.

   
 

Wit and wisdom
What we're saying and where we're saying it

   
 

Colby: Love It and Leave It
Colby ranks in top 10 of students who go abroad.

   

Iphigeneia's Truth: Revisiting classical themes as war looms

By William D. Adams

It now seems virtually certain that the United States will go to war with Iraq. The United Nations resolution will first require the shadow play of inspections, but just beyond the likely failure of that enterprise the real war looms with a tragic aura of inevitability. And tragic is the word. I was reminded of that last weekend while watching students at Colby perform a classical tragedy about that same aura, written two and a half millennia ago.


Iphigeneia is carried away to be sacrifieced byt the ancestral shades in Colby's production of Iph . . . by Colin Teevan. From left are David Cheng '06, Aimée Jack '04, Karin Shankar '05 and Anuradha Bhatnagar '06.

In Iph . . . , Colin Teevan's fine contemporary adaptation of Euripides's Iphigeneia at Aulis, the goddess Artemis is said to require that Iphigeneia, daughter of Agamemnon and Clytemnestra, be sacrificed before the Greek fleet is allowed to sail off to war with Troy. The chilling and still resonant truth of the play--we sacrifice our children for the nation, "for Greece!"--was made all the more ironic by listening to these children--our students, our children, Iphigeneia's distant successors--speak it.

Teevan's reworking of Euripides's story is especially relevant now because of its stark insistence that the sacrifice that is called for in war is concrete, immediate, personal and inescapable, no matter how smart the bombs and irrespective of the histories and accents of the children falling beneath the knives.

By some historical measures (the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution comes to mind), the debate preceding the congressional resolution supporting the use of force in Iraq was reasonably full. And the divisions in American public opinion regarding the necessity and wisdom of war express an appropriate level of turmoil.

But so far, most of the discussion about the prospect of war--supportive and critical--has been eerily abstract. The war planners are focused, reasonably enough, on operational matters. Politicians worry about immediate and long-term costs, both financial and political. Supporters and critics alike muse fretfully about post-war Iraq and the immense political complexities lurking there. Pervading all is the preoccupation with the technology of warfare--Saddam's weapons of mass destruction and the remarkable American arsenal of smart bombs and war machines, in particular.

What has not been much discussed, except in the most clinical way, are the bloody details of suffering and death. How many American and Iraqi battlefield casualties? How and where will those casualties occur? How many civilians--men, women and children--will die under the various planning scenarios?

It is natural to avoid such issues before any war, I am sure, but we are more prone to that avoidance now precisely because of the highly technological aspect of the contemporary battlefield and our connection to it. In the coming war in Iraq, we face the surreal prospect of watching televised images of unmanned drones producing televised images of their own laser-guided missiles striking targets thousands of feet away. What we will not see, and what we are now failing to imagine with appropriate intensity, is the horror beneath.

The truth of Iphigeneia consists in its willingness to entertain the necessity of war even as it reveals and inspects its horror. Iphigeneia herself--daughter, citizen, victim--ultimately assents to the logic of necessity. The fullness of the misery her sacrifice produced, however, is never suppressed. It remains front and center in the keening presence of Clytemnestra, who is at once this mother and all mothers. She will not bend to the logic of necessity; she will not forget.

Iphigeneia was first produced near the end of the brutal Peloponnesian War, in which Sparta defeated the Athenian Empire. Appropriately, Teevan rediscovered and applied the play's meaning in the vengeful cycle of politics in Northern Ireland.

Alas, we have no national theater or tragic festival to remind us of certain things as we prepare for our own departure. But as I watched our students performing this work, I was grateful for the more local insight it provided. And I was reinforced in my conviction that a true political education for the demanding world our children must soon inherit and lead requires more than an acquaintance with history, cultures, diplomacy, strategies and the dynamics of power, as if that weren't enough. It must also involve a close encounter with the tragic moral vision of human conflict that Euripides so clearly understood.

It would be a good thing if the President and his senior staff were to have a private showing of Iph . . . before our own troops depart for Iraq. We could then be more certain that the full force of what is about to happen to our children, and theirs, is apparent to those who give the orders. I am sure that Colby's undergraduates would be willing to take the show on the road.


William D. Adams, Colby's 19th president, is a Vietnam War veteran.

A similar version was published as "See the Tragedy of March to War" on January 12, 2003 in the Baltimore Sun.

 


FEATURES:
Dark Days
Students, alumni and healthcare providers talk depression and
the ways they address it at Colby.

Peace in Phnom Penh
Jim Cousins '75 has found refuge, rejuvination in the still-rebuilding Cambodian capital.

A Liberal Arts Resume
What did successful alumni in the business world study at Colby?

8 Mile High
With Eminem on his client list, entertainment lawyer Randall Cutler '91 is all about hip hop.

letters  |  editor's note  |  periscope  |  on campus   |  students  |  faculty  |  media
sports  |  development  |  alumni/class notes  |  obituaries  |  last page

© Colby College   Colby Magazine   4181 Mayflower Hill   Waterville, Maine 04901-8841
T: 207-859-4354   F: 207-859-4349   subscribe   mag@colby.edu

colby magazine