Office of Communications (
“The Catastrophe That Wasn’t” | ScienceNOW | March 3, 2009

New scientific findings by geologist Robert Gastaldo of Colby College in Waterville, Maine, and colleagues call into question popular theories about the largest mass extinction in Earth’s history.

A paper reporting the results, by Gastaldo, South African scientist Johann Neveling, and two 2008 Colby undergraduate students, C. Kittinger “Kit” Clark and Sophie Newbury, appears in the March 2009 issue of GEOLOGY.

Tens of millions of years before dinosaurs roamed Earth, their ancestors were all but eliminated in a catastrophic event called the Permian Mass Extinction. The Permian period extended from 299 to 252.6 million years ago.

Ideas about the event’s impact on land animals and plants are based largely on records in the Karoo Basin in central South Africa, where the best fossil records from that time are found, and where Gastaldo and his students have worked since 2003 with support from the National Science Foundation.

Earlier analysis of the rock record by other scientists working in South Africa led them to hypothesize about the nature, scope, and timing of the mass die-off of prehistoric amphibians and reptiles. Those scientists claimed that one unique sedimentary layer in the Karoo Basin overlies fossils of the last reptiles of the Permian period (synapsids, including the genus Dicynodon). This layer has been dubbed “the dead zone” because of its absence of fossil remains. This dead zone was thought to be synchronous in time and space, marking the event across southern Africa and as far away as Antarctica.

Now Gastaldo and coauthors report that they have found conflicting stratigraphic evidence in the Karoo Basin. They discovered that this dead-zone layer, or event bed, is not found at the same physical position in the rock record at all places, even across the immediate landscape where it was first described. As such, it is not a reliable marker of the mass extinction of terrestrial animals, Gastaldo says.

Gastaldo said that the research proves “there is no evidence to support a terminal extinction event in the record of the Karoo Basin, based on the criterion of a unique event bed or dead zone.”

“The Permian-Triassic boundary marks the greatest extinction event in Earth’s history, with significant loss of biodiversity both on land and in the oceans,” said H. Richard Lane, a paleontologist and program director in the National Science Foundation’s Division of Earth Sciences, which funded the research. “Until this study, it was believed that the event was marked by unique rocks traceable across Southern Hemisphere continents,” he said. But this new research calls into question whether or not an end-Permian extinction event occurred on land.

Photo: Kit Clark ’08 and Sophie Newbury ’08 on location in the Karoo Basin.